Recipe #064 of 175North IndiaVegMains, rice & breads

Paneer Butter Masala

Soft paneer cubes in a silky, mildly sweet tomato-butter gravy with cream. The safe, popular vegetarian main on almost every North Indian wedding menu.

Base Batch

10 Pax

200 g (paneer + gravy)

Prep / Cook

50m

30 min

Difficulty

medium

Commercial Standard

Cost / Portion

₹51.94

Illustrative Book Rate

Paneer Butter Masala commercial catering dish
Standard Commercial BatchPhoto #064

Section 1 · At a Glance

10-Portion Production Baseline
Region
North India
Type
Vegetarian
Meal
Lunch; dinner
Difficulty
Medium
Prep
20 min
Cook
30 min
Yield
10 portions (2.0 kg)
Portion
200 g (paneer + gravy)
Diet (Chapter 4)
Veg
Cost per portion
₹51.94 (₹519.41 for 10 portions; illustrative rates)
Section 2 · Interactive Ingredient Workstation

Ingredients & Dynamic Pax Scaling Lab

Base formulated for 10 portions. Calibrate guest count, adjust catering buffer, or search specific ingredients below.

Calibrate Guest Count:
Slider Adjustment (10 - 1,000 Pax):10 Guests
10 Pax100 Pax250 Pax500 Pax750 Pax1,000 Pax
Catering Spill & Tasting Buffer:(Standard commercial safety margin)

Batch Ingredient Cost

₹519

10 portions @ ₹51.94

Raw Batch Weight

~2.47 kg

Total raw commodities

Equipment Capacity

1 × GN 1/1

Standard chafing inserts

Scaling Factor

1.0× Base

10 Pax reference base

Commercial Scaling Rule (Chapter 2): Salt, chilli, spices, and cooking water do not scale linearly at bulk commercial volume. Taste and calibrate at every scale; never scale salt blindly.
GroupIngredient10 (Base)50 (×5)100 (×10)500 (×50)Calculated (10 Pax)
GravyRipe tomatoes, roughly chopped800 g4 kg8 kg40 kg800 g
GravyOnions, sliced200 g1 kg2 kg10 kg200 g
GravyCashew nuts50 g250 g500 g2.5 kg50 g
GravyButter100 g500 g1 kg5 kg100 g
GravyCooking oil20 ml100 ml200 ml1 L20 ml
GravyGinger-garlic paste30 g150 g300 g1.5 kg30 g
GravyCoriander powder10 g50 g100 g500 g10 g
GravyCumin powder6 g30 g60 g300 g6 g
GravyKashmiri red chilli powder10 g50 g100 g500 g10 g
GravySugar10 g50 g100 g500 g10 g
GravySalt12 g60 g120 g600 g12 g
GravyWater250 ml1.25 L2.5 L12.5 L250 ml
MainPaneer, cut into cubes800 g4 kg8 kg40 kg800 g
FinishFresh cream150 ml750 ml1.5 L7.5 L150 ml
FinishKasuri methi (dried fenugreek leaves)5 g25 g50 g250 g5 g
FinishFresh coriander leaves, chopped15 g75 g150 g750 g15 g

* Scaling is linear from the base 10-portion quantities (×5, ×10, ×50). Quantities of 1,000 g or more are shown as kg; 1,000 ml or more as L.

* Salt, spice, chilli and water do not scale perfectly — always taste and adjust; never scale salt blindly.

Section 3 · Kitchen Execution SOPs

Step-by-Step Method & Critical Control Points (CCP)

Standard operating procedures with highlighted CCP warnings where execution failure compromises texture or food safety.

Kitchen Progress: 0 of 7 Steps Complete0%

Build the tomato base. Heat the oil; add onions and cook until soft and golden. Add tomatoes, cashew nuts, ginger-garlic paste, coriander powder, cumin powder and Kashmiri red chilli powder; cook until the tomatoes break down.

Cook until the oil separates — **⚠ CCP:** keep cooking on medium heat until oil glistens at the edges and the raw tomato smell is gone, about 15–20 minutes.

Critical Control Point (CCP Warning)⚠ CCP:** keep cooking on medium heat until oil glistens at the edges and the raw tomato smell is gone, about 15–20 minutes.

Blend. Cool slightly, blend to a smooth purée with the water, and pass through a sieve for a silky finish.

Make the gravy. Return the purée to the pan with 80 g of the butter; simmer 10 minutes. Add the salt and sugar; the gravy should coat the back of a spoon.

Add the paneer. Add the paneer cubes and simmer gently 5 minutes — **⚠ CCP:** do not boil hard, or the paneer turns rubbery.

Critical Control Point (CCP Warning)⚠ CCP:** do not boil hard, or the paneer turns rubbery.

Finish. Take the pan off the heat; stir in the cream and the remaining 20 g butter, then crush the kasuri methi between your palms and sprinkle it in.

Serve. Garnish with coriander leaves; serve hot, 200 g per portion. Done when: glossy, orange-red gravy, mild and buttery, paneer soft.

ℹ CCP = critical control point — the moment where getting it wrong spoils the dish or makes it unsafe.

Section 4 · Culinary Intelligence

Tips & Tricks + Common Mistakes to Avoid

✓Tips that work
  • •Sieve the blended base — it is the difference between a home gravy and a restaurant one.
  • •Soak paneer cubes in warm water for 10 minutes before adding if the paneer is firm.
  • •Add cream off the heat so the gravy never splits.
✗Common mistakes
  • •Boiling hard after adding paneer — rubbery paneer and a split gravy.
  • •Skipping the oil-separation stage — a pale, sour gravy.
  • •Adding cream to a boiling gravy — it splits.

Section 5 · Nutrition — (200 g (paneer + gravy)

Standard food-composition estimates derived from the raw ingredient list.

ESTIMATE — not lab-tested

Energy

330 kcal

Avg: 259 kcal

Protein

12 g

Avg: 10 g

Carbohydrate

14 g

Avg: 33 g

Fat

24 g

Avg: 10 g

Fibre

2 g

Avg: 2 g

Sodium

680 mg

Avg: 434 mg

Macro Energy Split (% of Caloric Intake)Hover segments for breakdown
Carbs

18%

14 g

Protein

15%

12 g

Fat

68%

24 g

Energy split: carbohydrate 18% · protein 15% · fat 68%.

Check: 4 × 12 g protein + 4 × 14 g carbohydrate + 9 × 24 g fat = 320 kcal, close to the stated 330 kcal (rounded estimate).

* Estimate from standard food-composition values for the ingredient list — not lab-tested; actual values vary. No health claim is made.

Section 6 · Fun Fact & Origin

Origin: not documented — no reliable source found for a single place, person or date of first creation. It developed as the vegetarian counterpart of butter chicken in Delhi–Punjabi restaurant cooking.

Section 7 · Regional Traditions

Paneer butter masala is a Delhi–Punjabi restaurant classic and the default vegetarian main at North Indian weddings. It is mild, rich and liked by almost every guest, which is why caterers put it on the menu when the guest list is mixed.

Section 8 · Menu Engineering

Three Commercial Variations

Restaurant-style

the recipe as written — sieved silky gravy, full butter and cream, kasuri methi finish.

Economical / Banquet

replace half the cashew with melon seeds and use half the cream, topped up with milk.

Healthier Alternative

use half the butter, replace half the cream with hung curd, and skip the sugar.

Section 9 · Commercial Kitchen SOPs

Production Intelligence & Banquet Logistics

Batch Yield

10 portions × 200 g = 2.0 kg finished.

Prep Schedule

Morning: make the tomato base a day ahead and chill. On the day: finish the gravy, add paneer within 30 minutes of service.

Portion Control

200 g per portion by ladle; weigh the first 5 portions of every batch.

Holding Limits

Hot hold 65°C

  • Yield: 10 portions × 200 g = 2.0 kg finished.
  • Prep schedule: Morning: make the tomato base a day ahead and chill. On the day: finish the gravy, add paneer within 30 minutes of service.
  • Portion control: 200 g per portion by ladle; weigh the first 5 portions of every batch.
  • Holding and service risks: Hold covered and hot; stir gently every 20 minutes. Do not hold for hours — the butter separates and the paneer hardens.
Section 10 · FSSAI & Hygiene Guidance

Food Safety, Allergens & Thermal Holding

Allergen Classification (Chapter 4 Matrix)

Contains — Milk, Nuts. Not present — Wheat, Egg, Fish, Soy, Mustard, Sesame. Diet: Veg.

•Allergens actually present in this dish (checked against §2):
•Milk — paneer, butter, fresh cream.
•Tree nuts — cashew nuts.
•Cook the tomato base fully; keep the finished dish hot and covered.
•Cool leftovers quickly; reheat gently and only once. Keep veg and non-veg vessels and ladles separate.
ℹ Disclaimer: Allergen tags represent book guidance from the ingredient specifications. Caterers must verify raw supplier packaging for factory cross-contact allergens.
Section 11 · Institutional Commercial Insight

Ingredient Costing, Pairings & Waste Reduction

Per Portion Cost

₹51.94

Cost per portion = (sum of ingredient quantity × rate) ÷ portions. Ingredient cost only — water, cooking fuel, transport, labour, and commercial overheads are not included. All rates are illustrative book planning benchmarks; replace with your live mandi rates.

Cost Driver Composition

10-Portion Base
₹51.94Per Portion
Paneer, cut into cubes
₹304.0059%
Butter
₹55.0011%
Fresh cream
₹48.009%
Cashew nuts
₹45.009%
Spices & Other
₹67.4113%
Sum of Batch Ingredients:₹519.41 / 10 Pax

Interactive Margin & Profit Simulator

Calibrate your catering client quote to verify commercial profit margins.

Optimal Margin (67%)
₹
Pricing Multipliers:
Simulate Catering Batch (100 Pax):

Quoted Revenue

₹15,600

Food Cost

₹5,194

Gross Profit

₹10,406

IngredientQuantityIllustrative RateCost (₹)
Ripe tomatoes, roughly chopped800 g₹40/kg₹32.00
Onions, sliced200 g₹35/kg₹7.00
Cashew nuts50 g₹900/kg₹45.00
Butter100 g₹550/kg₹55.00
Cooking oil20 ml₹170/L₹3.40
Ginger-garlic paste30 g₹200/kg₹6.00
Coriander powder10 g₹400/kg₹4.00
Cumin powder6 g₹450/kg₹2.70
Kashmiri red chilli powder10 g₹450/kg₹4.50
Paneer, cut into cubes800 g₹380/kg₹304.00
Fresh cream150 ml₹320/L₹48.00
Kasuri methi (dried fenugreek leaves)5 g₹800/kg₹4.00
Fresh coriander leaves, chopped15 g₹200/kg₹3.00
Small items combinedSugar, Salt—₹0.81
Position in the book: premium end — costs more than 88% of the 175 dishes.

Kitchen Waste Reduction & Yield Strategy

Leftover gravy freezes well in 10-portion packs; day-old paneer cubes go into a paneer bhurji the same day.

* Please test this dish in your own kitchen first — quantities are a starting point, not a tasted guarantee. All rates in §11 are illustrative; replace them with your own live supplier / APMC rates.