Recipe #066 of 175North IndiaVegMains, rice & breads

Dal Makhani

Slow-cooked black urad dal with butter and cream — dark, creamy and mild. The dal that every North Indian wedding menu carries, and the one that improves with slow cooking.

Base Batch

10 Pax

200 g

Prep / Cook

105m

1 hour 30 min

Difficulty

easy

Commercial Standard

Cost / Portion

₹18.95

Illustrative Book Rate

Dal Makhani commercial catering dish
Standard Commercial BatchPhoto #066

Section 1 · At a Glance

10-Portion Production Baseline
Region
North India
Type
Vegetarian
Meal
Lunch; dinner
Difficulty
Easy
Prep
15 min + overnight soaking
Cook
1 hour 30 min
Yield
10 portions (2.0 kg)
Portion
200 g
Diet (Chapter 4)
Veg
Cost per portion
₹18.95 (₹189.46 for 10 portions; illustrative rates)
Section 2 · Interactive Ingredient Workstation

Ingredients & Dynamic Pax Scaling Lab

Base formulated for 10 portions. Calibrate guest count, adjust catering buffer, or search specific ingredients below.

Calibrate Guest Count:
Slider Adjustment (10 - 1,000 Pax):10 Guests
10 Pax100 Pax250 Pax500 Pax750 Pax1,000 Pax
Catering Spill & Tasting Buffer:(Standard commercial safety margin)

Batch Ingredient Cost

₹190

10 portions @ ₹18.95

Raw Batch Weight

~2.69 kg

Total raw commodities

Equipment Capacity

1 × GN 1/1

Standard chafing inserts

Scaling Factor

1.0× Base

10 Pax reference base

Commercial Scaling Rule (Chapter 2): Salt, chilli, spices, and cooking water do not scale linearly at bulk commercial volume. Taste and calibrate at every scale; never scale salt blindly.
GroupIngredient10 (Base)50 (×5)100 (×10)500 (×50)Calculated (10 Pax)
DalWhole black urad dal, dry400 g2 kg4 kg20 kg400 g
DalRed kidney beans (rajma), dry100 g500 g1 kg5 kg100 g
DalWater, for cooking1.5 L7.5 L15 L75 L1.5 L
DalSalt12 g60 g120 g600 g12 g
MasalaOnions, finely chopped150 g750 g1.5 kg7.5 kg150 g
MasalaTomatoes, chopped250 g1.25 kg2.5 kg12.5 kg250 g
MasalaGinger-garlic paste25 g125 g250 g1.25 kg25 g
MasalaButter80 g400 g800 g4 kg80 g
MasalaCooking oil15 ml75 ml150 ml750 ml15 ml
MasalaCumin seeds5 g25 g50 g250 g5 g
MasalaCoriander powder8 g40 g80 g400 g8 g
MasalaKashmiri red chilli powder8 g40 g80 g400 g8 g
MasalaGaram masala5 g25 g50 g250 g5 g
FinishFresh cream100 ml500 ml1 L5 L100 ml
FinishButter, to finish20 g100 g200 g1 kg20 g
FinishFresh coriander leaves, chopped10 g50 g100 g500 g10 g

* Scaling is linear from the base 10-portion quantities (×5, ×10, ×50). Quantities of 1,000 g or more are shown as kg; 1,000 ml or more as L.

* Salt, spice, chilli and water do not scale perfectly — always taste and adjust; never scale salt blindly.

Section 3 · Kitchen Execution SOPs

Step-by-Step Method & Critical Control Points (CCP)

Standard operating procedures with highlighted CCP warnings where execution failure compromises texture or food safety.

Kitchen Progress: 0 of 7 Steps Complete0%

Soak the dal and rajma overnight in plenty of water. Drain and rinse.

Cook the dal. Pressure-cook with the 1.5 L water and half the salt until completely soft — about 25–30 minutes. **⚠ CCP:** the dal must be fully soft; undercooked urad never softens later.

Critical Control Point (CCP Warning)⚠ CCP:** the dal must be fully soft; undercooked urad never softens later.

Mash lightly. Mash the cooked dal a few times with a ladle until creamy but not a paste.

Make the masala. Heat the oil with 80 g butter; add cumin, then onion and ginger-garlic paste; cook until golden. Add tomatoes, coriander powder, Kashmiri red chilli powder and garam masala; cook until oil separates.

Combine and simmer. Add the cooked dal with its water to the masala; simmer on low heat 45–60 minutes, stirring often — **⚠ CCP:** slow simmering is what makes dal makhani creamy; do not rush it. Add hot water if it thickens too much.

Critical Control Point (CCP Warning)⚠ CCP:** slow simmering is what makes dal makhani creamy; do not rush it.

Finish. Add the remaining salt, the cream and 20 g butter; simmer 5 minutes more.

Serve. Garnish with coriander leaves; serve hot, 200 g per portion. Done when: dark, creamy, flowing slowly off the ladle, buttery finish.

ℹ CCP = critical control point — the moment where getting it wrong spoils the dish or makes it unsafe.

Section 4 · Culinary Intelligence

Tips & Tricks + Common Mistakes to Avoid

✓Tips that work
  • •Soak a full night — short-soaked urad stays hard whatever the cooking time.
  • •Simmer long and slow; the creaminess comes from time, not from more cream.
  • •Stir often during the long simmer so the dal does not catch at the bottom.
✗Common mistakes
  • •Grainy dal — undercooked, or not mashed at all.
  • •Thin dal — too much water added at the end; add hot water a little at a time.
  • •Burnt bottom — simmered too high without stirring.

Section 5 · Nutrition — (200 g)

Standard food-composition estimates derived from the raw ingredient list.

ESTIMATE — not lab-tested

Energy

280 kcal

Avg: 259 kcal

Protein

11 g

Avg: 10 g

Carbohydrate

30 g

Avg: 33 g

Fat

13 g

Avg: 10 g

Fibre

5 g

Avg: 2 g

Sodium

620 mg

Avg: 434 mg

Macro Energy Split (% of Caloric Intake)Hover segments for breakdown
Carbs

43%

30 g

Protein

16%

11 g

Fat

42%

13 g

Energy split: carbohydrate 43% · protein 16% · fat 42%.

Check: 4 × 11 g protein + 4 × 30 g carbohydrate + 9 × 13 g fat = 281 kcal, close to the stated 280 kcal (rounded estimate).

* Estimate from standard food-composition values for the ingredient list — not lab-tested; actual values vary. No health claim is made.

Section 6 · Fun Fact & Origin

Origin: not documented — no reliable source found for a single place, person or date of first creation. Slow-cooked black dal is a long-standing Punjabi tradition; no inventor is recorded.

Section 7 · Regional Traditions

Dal makhani is a Punjabi classic and a fixture of North Indian wedding menus. It is the dal that holds best on a buffet — it improves with slow cooking and reheats well — so caterers cook it early and hold it through service.

Section 8 · Menu Engineering

Three Commercial Variations

Restaurant-style

simmer longer, finish with extra butter and cream, and serve with a cream swirl on top.

Economical / Banquet

reduce the butter and cream by half; the long simmer still gives a creamy result.

Healthier Alternative

use less butter, replace half the cream with milk, and keep the salt as written.

Section 9 · Commercial Kitchen SOPs

Production Intelligence & Banquet Logistics

Batch Yield

10 portions × 200 g = 2.0 kg finished.

Prep Schedule

Previous evening: soak dal and rajma. Morning: cook dal, make masala, simmer slowly; finish within 30 minutes of service.

Portion Control

200 g per portion by ladle; weigh the first 5 portions of every batch.

Holding Limits

Hot hold 65°C

  • Yield: 10 portions × 200 g = 2.0 kg finished.
  • Prep schedule: Previous evening: soak dal and rajma. Morning: cook dal, make masala, simmer slowly; finish within 30 minutes of service.
  • Portion control: 200 g per portion by ladle; weigh the first 5 portions of every batch.
  • Holding and service risks: Holds well hot for a full service; stir often. Reheats well the same day — add a little hot water when reheating.
Section 10 · FSSAI & Hygiene Guidance

Food Safety, Allergens & Thermal Holding

Allergen Classification (Chapter 4 Matrix)

Contains — Milk. Not present — Wheat, Egg, Fish, Nuts, Soy, Mustard, Sesame. Diet: Veg.

•Allergens actually present in this dish (checked against §2):
•Milk — butter and fresh cream.
•Cook the dal fully; keep the finished dish hot and covered.
•Cool leftovers quickly; reheat thoroughly and only once.
ℹ Disclaimer: Allergen tags represent book guidance from the ingredient specifications. Caterers must verify raw supplier packaging for factory cross-contact allergens.
Section 11 · Institutional Commercial Insight

Ingredient Costing, Pairings & Waste Reduction

Per Portion Cost

₹18.95

Cost per portion = (sum of ingredient quantity × rate) ÷ portions. Ingredient cost only — water, cooking fuel, transport, labour, and commercial overheads are not included. All rates are illustrative book planning benchmarks; replace with your live mandi rates.

Cost Driver Composition

10-Portion Base
₹18.95Per Portion
Whole black urad dal, dry
₹52.0027%
Butter
₹44.0023%
Fresh cream
₹32.0017%
Red kidney beans (rajma), dry
₹12.006%
Spices & Other
₹49.4626%
Sum of Batch Ingredients:₹189.46 / 10 Pax

Interactive Margin & Profit Simulator

Calibrate your catering client quote to verify commercial profit margins.

Optimal Margin (67%)
₹
Pricing Multipliers:
Simulate Catering Batch (100 Pax):

Quoted Revenue

₹5,700

Food Cost

₹1,895

Gross Profit

₹3,805

IngredientQuantityIllustrative RateCost (₹)
Whole black urad dal, dry400 g₹130/kg₹52.00
Red kidney beans (rajma), dry100 g₹120/kg₹12.00
Onions, finely chopped150 g₹35/kg₹5.25
Tomatoes, chopped250 g₹40/kg₹10.00
Ginger-garlic paste25 g₹200/kg₹5.00
Butter80 g₹550/kg₹44.00
Cooking oil15 ml₹170/L₹2.55
Cumin seeds5 g₹600/kg₹3.00
Coriander powder8 g₹400/kg₹3.20
Kashmiri red chilli powder8 g₹450/kg₹3.60
Garam masala5 g₹700/kg₹3.50
Fresh cream100 ml₹320/L₹32.00
Butter, to finish20 g₹550/kg₹11.00
Fresh coriander leaves, chopped10 g₹200/kg₹2.00
Small items combinedSalt—₹0.36
Position in the book: premium end — costs more than 62% of the 175 dishes.

Kitchen Waste Reduction & Yield Strategy

Leftover dal makhani reheats well the same day and makes a good filling for dal-stuffed parathas; dal cooking water is kept in the dish, not thrown away.

* Please test this dish in your own kitchen first — quantities are a starting point, not a tasted guarantee. All rates in §11 are illustrative; replace them with your own live supplier / APMC rates.