Recipe #147 of 175West IndiaVegMains, rice & breads

Batata Nu Shaak

Gujarat's everyday potato curry — soft potatoes in a mild, slightly sweet tomato-spice gravy, the shaak of the daily thali.

Base Batch

10 Pax

175 g

Prep / Cook

40m

25 min

Difficulty

easy–medium

Commercial Standard

Cost / Portion

₹6.15

Illustrative Book Rate

Batata Nu Shaak commercial catering dish
Standard Commercial BatchPhoto #147

Section 1 · At a Glance

10-Portion Production Baseline
Region
West India
Vegetarian
Yes
Meal
Lunch; dinner; thali service
Service
Buffet; thali
Difficulty
Easy–medium
Prep
15 min
Cook
25 min
Yield
10 portions
Portion
175 g
Category
Vegetarian
Diet (Chapter 4)
Veg
Cost per portion
₹6.15 (₹61.50 for 10 portions; illustrative rates)
Section 2 · Interactive Ingredient Workstation

Ingredients & Dynamic Pax Scaling Lab

Base formulated for 10 portions. Calibrate guest count, adjust catering buffer, or search specific ingredients below.

Calibrate Guest Count:
Slider Adjustment (10 - 1,000 Pax):10 Guests
10 Pax100 Pax250 Pax500 Pax750 Pax1,000 Pax
Catering Spill & Tasting Buffer:(Standard commercial safety margin)

Batch Ingredient Cost

₹62

10 portions @ ₹6.15

Raw Batch Weight

~1.87 kg

Total raw commodities

Equipment Capacity

1 × GN 1/1

Standard chafing inserts

Scaling Factor

1.0× Base

10 Pax reference base

Commercial Scaling Rule (Chapter 2): Salt, chilli, spices, and cooking water do not scale linearly at bulk commercial volume. Taste and calibrate at every scale; never scale salt blindly.
GroupIngredient10 (Base)50 (×5)100 (×10)500 (×50)Calculated (10 Pax)
MainPotatoes, peeled and cubed1 kg5 kg10 kg50 kg1 kg
MainTomatoes, chopped300 g1.5 kg3 kg15 kg300 g
MainOil50 ml250 ml500 ml2.5 L50 ml
MainMustard seeds5 g25 g50 g250 g5 g
MainCumin seeds5 g25 g50 g250 g5 g
MainAsafoetida (hing)2 g10 g20 g100 g2 g
MainGinger-green chilli paste20 g100 g200 g1 kg20 g
MainTurmeric powder5 g25 g50 g250 g5 g
MainRed chilli powder8 g40 g80 g400 g8 g
MainCoriander powder12 g60 g120 g600 g12 g
MainCumin powder8 g40 g80 g400 g8 g
MainSalt13 g65 g130 g650 g13 g
MainSugar10 g50 g100 g500 g10 g
MainWater400 ml2 L4 L20 L400 ml
GarnishFresh coriander leaves, chopped20 g100 g200 g1 kg20 g
GarnishLemon juice10 ml50 ml100 ml500 ml10 ml

* Scaling — linear from base 10 (×5, ×10, ×50). Above 1,000 g shown as kg; above 1,000 ml as L. For 50+ portions, cook in

* separate 50-portion vessels — a single larger pot cooks the potatoes unevenly and the bottom ones turn to mush.

Section 3 · Kitchen Execution SOPs

Step-by-Step Method & Critical Control Points (CCP)

Standard operating procedures with highlighted CCP warnings where execution failure compromises texture or food safety.

Kitchen Progress: 0 of 7 Steps Complete0%

Temper. Heat the oil; add mustard seeds, cumin and asafoetida, then ginger-green chilli paste; fry until fragrant.

Build the masala. Add tomatoes, turmeric, chilli powder, coriander and cumin powders, salt and sugar. Cook 5–6 minutes until the tomatoes break down and the oil separates at the edges.

Add the potatoes. Add the potato cubes and the 400 ml water. Stir once to coat. **⚠ CCP—** water: just enough to cook the potatoes; too much makes a watery shaak.

Critical Control Point (CCP Warning)⚠ CCP—** water: just enough to cook the potatoes; too much makes a watery shaak.

Cook covered. Cover and cook on medium-low heat 15–18 minutes until the potatoes are soft. **⚠ CCP—** doneness: a knife slides through a cube easily; the cubes must stay whole, not collapse.

Critical Control Point (CCP Warning)⚠ CCP—** doneness: a knife slides through a cube easily; the cubes must stay whole, not collapse.

Check the gravy. The gravy should lightly coat the potatoes — neither dry nor watery. If too thin, cook uncovered 2–3 minutes; if too dry, add a little hot water.

Finish. Add lemon juice and coriander, mix once, and rest 5 minutes. Done when: potatoes soft and whole, gravy clinging, mild and lightly sweet, no raw-spice taste.

Serve. 175 g per portion. Serve hot with roti, thepla or rice.

ℹ CCP = critical control point — the moment where getting it wrong spoils the dish or makes it unsafe.

Section 4 · Culinary Intelligence

Tips & Tricks + Common Mistakes to Avoid

✓Tips that work
  • •Cut the potato cubes to one size so they cook in the same time.
  • •Cook covered on medium-low heat — high heat burns the masala before the potatoes cook.
  • •Add the lemon at the end, off the heat, so it stays bright.
✗Common mistakes
  • •Uneven cubes — small ones dissolve while big ones stay hard.
  • •Too much water — a watery shaak that slides off the roti.
  • •Stirring hard after the potatoes soften — they break and the dish turns pasty.

Section 5 · Nutrition — (175 g)

Standard food-composition estimates derived from the raw ingredient list.

ESTIMATE — not lab-tested

Energy

163 kcal

Avg: 259 kcal

Protein

3 g

Avg: 10 g

Carbohydrate

26 g

Avg: 33 g

Fat

5 g

Avg: 10 g

Fibre

3 g

Avg: 2 g

Sodium

460 mg

Avg: 434 mg

Macro Energy Split (% of Caloric Intake)Hover segments for breakdown
Carbs

65%

26 g

Protein

7%

3 g

Fat

28%

5 g

Energy split: carbohydrate 65% · protein 7% · fat 28%.

Check: 3×4 + 26×4 + 5×9 = 161 kcal, stated 163 kcal (rounded estimate).

* Estimate from standard food-composition values for the ingredient list — not lab-tested; actual values vary. No health claim is made.

Section 6 · Fun Fact & Origin

'Shaak' is the Gujarati word for a cooked vegetable dish — batata nu shaak is simply 'potato vegetable', and it is the dish Gujarati cooks reach for when the thali needs a reliable, mild, everyday main that every guest will eat. Origin: not documented — no reliable source found for a single inventor, place or date.

Section 7 · Regional Traditions

Batata nu shaak belongs to Gujarat, where it is the everyday shaak of the thali — served with dal, rice and roti at lunch and dinner, at home and at weddings. It is deliberately mild and lightly sweet, in the Gujarati style, so it suits children and older guests.

Section 8 · Menu Engineering

Three Commercial Variations

Restaurant-style

Add 100 g green peas and finish with 30 g fresh cream stirred in off the heat; serve with buttered roti.

Economical / Banquet

Cut the oil to 30 ml. Saves about ₹0.30 per portion (see §11).

Healthier Alternative

Cut the oil to 30 ml, skip the sugar, and add 150 g cauliflower with the potatoes.

Section 9 · Commercial Kitchen SOPs

Production Intelligence & Banquet Logistics

Batch Yield

10 portions × 175 g = about 1.75 kg from 1 kg potatoes + 300 g tomatoes.

Prep Schedule

Standard prep

Portion Control

one level 175 ml ladle = one 175 g portion. Weigh the first five portions.

Holding Limits

Hot hold 65°C

  • Yield: 10 portions × 175 g = about 1.75 kg from 1 kg potatoes + 300 g tomatoes.
  • Prep schedule (100 portions): peel and cube the potatoes the morning of the event, kept in water so they do not darken; cook in two 50-portion vessels (~25 min per vessel).
  • Portion control: one level 175 ml ladle = one 175 g portion. Weigh the first five portions.
  • Holding and service risks: hold covered in service vessels; replenish in small batches so the first servings do not dry out. loosen with a little hot water and stir gently before each ladle.
Section 10 · FSSAI & Hygiene Guidance

Food Safety, Allergens & Thermal Holding

Allergen Classification (Chapter 4 Matrix)

Contains — Mustard. Not present — Milk, Wheat, Egg, Fish, Nuts, Soy, Sesame. Diet: Veg.

•Allergens actually present in this dish (checked against §2):
•Mustard — mustard seeds in the tempering.
•Gluten — only if the asafoetida is wheat-compounded. Check the pack: if it lists wheat flour, the dish contains gluten — use certified gluten-free asafoetida or leave it out, and say so on the menu.
•Not present: egg, milk, peanut, tree nuts, soy, sesame, fish. Safe cooking and handling:
•Cook the potatoes through — no hard centres in the finished dish.
•Keep hot and covered; serve in small batches.
•Discard leftovers at the end of service.
•Store potatoes cool, dry and dark; discard any potato with green patches or sprouts before cooking.
ℹ Disclaimer: Allergen tags represent book guidance from the ingredient specifications. Caterers must verify raw supplier packaging for factory cross-contact allergens.
Section 11 · Institutional Commercial Insight

Ingredient Costing, Pairings & Waste Reduction

Per Portion Cost

₹6.15

Cost per portion = (sum of ingredient quantity × rate) ÷ portions. Ingredient cost only — water, cooking fuel, transport, labour, and commercial overheads are not included. All rates are illustrative book planning benchmarks; replace with your live mandi rates.

Cost Driver Composition

10-Portion Base
₹6.15Per Portion
Potatoes
₹30.0049%
Tomatoes
₹12.0020%
Spices, salt, sugar & aromatics (combined)
₹12.0020%
Oil
₹7.5012%
Sum of Batch Ingredients:₹61.50 / 10 Pax

Interactive Margin & Profit Simulator

Calibrate your catering client quote to verify commercial profit margins.

Optimal Margin (66%)
₹
Pricing Multipliers:
Simulate Catering Batch (100 Pax):

Quoted Revenue

₹1,800

Food Cost

₹615

Gross Profit

₹1,185

IngredientQuantityIllustrative RateCost (₹)
Potatoes1 kg₹30 / kg₹30.00
Tomatoes300 g₹40 / kg₹12.00
Oil50 ml₹150 / L₹7.50
Spices, salt, sugar & aromatics (combined)——₹12.00
Position in the book: lower ingredient cost than 86% of the 175 dishes.

Profitable Menu Pairings

Kitchen Waste Reduction & Yield Strategy

The biggest waste is potatoes overcooked to mush on long holding.

* Please test this dish in your own kitchen first — quantities are a starting point, not a tasted guarantee. All rates in §11 are illustrative; replace them with your own live supplier / APMC rates.