Recipe #121 of 175East IndiaNon-vegMains, rice & breads

Machher Jhol

Light everyday fish curry with potato and tomato in a thin, cumin-scented gravy — the Bengali daily fish curry, eaten with rice at lunch.

Base Batch

10 Pax

1 fish piece (about 120 g) + gravy

Prep / Cook

45m

25 min

Difficulty

easy

Commercial Standard

Cost / Portion

₹46.95

Illustrative Book Rate

Machher Jhol commercial catering dish
Standard Commercial BatchPhoto #121

Section 1 · At a Glance

10-Portion Production Baseline
Region
East India (West Bengal)
Type
Non-vegetarian (fish)
Meal
Lunch
Difficulty
Easy
Prep
20 min
Cook
25 min
Yield
10 portions
Portion
1 fish piece (about 120 g) + gravy
Diet (Chapter 4)
Non-veg
Cost per portion
₹46.95 (₹469.50 for 10 portions; illustrative rates)
Section 2 · Interactive Ingredient Workstation

Ingredients & Dynamic Pax Scaling Lab

Base formulated for 10 portions. Calibrate guest count, adjust catering buffer, or search specific ingredients below.

Calibrate Guest Count:
Slider Adjustment (10 - 1,000 Pax):10 Guests
10 Pax100 Pax250 Pax500 Pax750 Pax1,000 Pax
Catering Spill & Tasting Buffer:(Standard commercial safety margin)

Batch Ingredient Cost

₹470

10 portions @ ₹46.95

Raw Batch Weight

~2.78 kg

Total raw commodities

Equipment Capacity

1 × GN 1/1

Standard chafing inserts

Scaling Factor

1.0× Base

10 Pax reference base

Commercial Scaling Rule (Chapter 2): Salt, chilli, spices, and cooking water do not scale linearly at bulk commercial volume. Taste and calibrate at every scale; never scale salt blindly.
GroupIngredient10 (Base)50 (×5)100 (×10)500 (×50)Calculated (10 Pax)
MainRohu fish pieces, cleaned1.2 kg6.0 kg12.0 kg60.0 kg1.2 kg
MainPotatoes, cut into wedges300 g1.5 kg3.0 kg15.0 kg300 g
MainTomatoes, chopped200 g1.0 kg2.0 kg10.0 kg200 g
MainOnions, sliced150 g750 g1.5 kg7.5 kg150 g
MainGinger paste20 g100 g200 g1.0 kg20 g
MainTurmeric powder5 g25 g50 g250 g5 g
MainRed chilli powder5 g25 g50 g250 g5 g
MainCumin powder10 g50 g100 g500 g10 g
MainGreen chillies, slit10 g50 g100 g500 g10 g
MainMustard oil50 ml250 ml500 ml2.5 L50 ml
MainPanch phoron5 g25 g50 g250 g5 g
MainBay leaves1 nos5 nos10 nos50 nos1 nos
MainSalt12 g60 g120 g600 g12 g
MainWater800 ml4.0 L8.0 L40.0 L800 ml
GarnishFresh coriander leaves, chopped10 g50 g100 g500 g10 g

* Salt, spice and chilli: taste and adjust to your own ingredients — they do not scale perfectly. Water: adjust to your rice, dal and vegetables.

* Scaling — linear from base 10 (×5, ×10, ×50). Above 1,000 g shown as kg; above 1,000 ml as L.

Section 3 · Kitchen Execution SOPs

Step-by-Step Method & Critical Control Points (CCP)

Standard operating procedures with highlighted CCP warnings where execution failure compromises texture or food safety.

Kitchen Progress: 0 of 5 Steps Complete0%

Marinate and fry. Rub fish with turmeric and half the salt; rest 10 minutes. Heat mustard oil; fry fish pieces 2 minutes a side until lightly golden. Lift out. **⚠ CCP—** frying: do not cook the fish through here; it finishes in the gravy.

Critical Control Point (CCP Warning)⚠ CCP—** frying: do not cook the fish through here; it finishes in the gravy.

Build the gravy. In the same oil add bay leaf and panch phoron; fry onions until soft. Add ginger paste, tomatoes, red chilli and cumin powders; cook until the oil separates.

Cook the potatoes. Add potatoes and 800 ml water; simmer 10 minutes until the potatoes are nearly tender.

Add the fish. Slide the fish in gently with green chillies and the remaining salt. Simmer 8–10 minutes until the fish is opaque and flakes easily. **⚠ CCP—** fish: it is done when it flakes; overcooking breaks the pieces.

Critical Control Point (CCP Warning)⚠ CCP—** fish: it is done when it flakes; overcooking breaks the pieces.

Serve 1 piece per portion with gravy and potato, garnished with coriander. Done when: fish flaking, potatoes tender, gravy thin and fragrant, not thick.

ℹ CCP = critical control point — the moment where getting it wrong spoils the dish or makes it unsafe.

Section 4 · Culinary Intelligence

Tips & Tricks + Common Mistakes to Avoid

✓Tips that work
  • •Fry the fish lightly — it keeps its shape in the gravy.
  • •Use hot water for the gravy so the fish does not cool and toughen.
  • •Keep the gravy thin — this is a jhol, not a thick curry.
✗Common mistakes
  • •Overcooked fish — broken pieces in the gravy.
  • •Thick gravy — it stops being machher jhol.
  • •Cold water in the gravy — the fish toughens.

Section 5 · Nutrition — (1 fish piece (about 120 g)

Standard food-composition estimates derived from the raw ingredient list.

ESTIMATE — not lab-tested

Energy

260 kcal

Avg: 259 kcal

Protein

26 g

Avg: 10 g

Carbohydrate

6 g

Avg: 33 g

Fat

13 g

Avg: 10 g

Fibre

1 g

Avg: 2 g

Sodium

560 mg

Avg: 434 mg

Macro Energy Split (% of Caloric Intake)Hover segments for breakdown
Carbs

10%

6 g

Protein

42%

26 g

Fat

48%

13 g

Energy split: carbohydrate 10% · protein 42% · fat 48%.

* Estimate from standard food-composition values for the ingredient list — not lab-tested; actual values vary. No health claim is made.

Section 6 · Fun Fact & Origin

Origin: not documented — no reliable source found.

Section 7 · Regional Traditions

Machher jhol is the everyday fish curry of West Bengal, the daily lunch curry eaten with steamed rice; every Bengali home has its own version, and it is the fish course most often served at weddings after shukto and dal.

Section 8 · Menu Engineering

Three Commercial Variations

Restaurant-style

Use larger rohu pieces and finish with a little ghee.

Economical / Banquet

Use smaller fish pieces and more potato.

Healthier Alternative

Use less mustard oil and more tomato.

Section 9 · Commercial Kitchen SOPs

Production Intelligence & Banquet Logistics

Batch Yield

10 fish pieces + about 1.2 L gravy.

Prep Schedule

clean and fry fish the morning of the event; make the gravy base ahead; add fish and finish within 30 minutes of service.

Portion Control

1 piece per plate; ladle gravy and potato over.

Holding Limits

holds covered for 1 hour; fish breaks up on long holding.

  • Yield: 10 fish pieces + about 1.2 L gravy.
  • Prep schedule: clean and fry fish the morning of the event; make the gravy base ahead; add fish and finish within 30 minutes of service.
  • Portion control: 1 piece per plate; ladle gravy and potato over.
  • Holding: holds covered for 1 hour; fish breaks up on long holding.
  • Service risk: broken fish — stir gently and serve with a wide ladle.
Section 10 · FSSAI & Hygiene Guidance

Food Safety, Allergens & Thermal Holding

Allergen Classification (Chapter 4 Matrix)

Contains — Fish, Mustard. Not present — Milk, Wheat, Egg, Nuts, Soy, Sesame. Diet: Non-veg.

•Allergens in this dish (checked against the ingredient list): Fish (rohu). Mustard (mustard oil). No wheat, milk, egg, nut or sesame in this recipe. Keep fish chilled until cooking and cook it through until it flakes and is opaque. Keep raw fish away from ready-to-eat food; use separate boards and knives. Cool leftovers quickly, cover and refrigerate; reheat gently and only once. Tell the service team this dish contains fish and mustard.
ℹ Disclaimer: Allergen tags represent book guidance from the ingredient specifications. Caterers must verify raw supplier packaging for factory cross-contact allergens.
Section 11 · Institutional Commercial Insight

Ingredient Costing, Pairings & Waste Reduction

Per Portion Cost

₹46.95

Cost per portion = (sum of ingredient quantity × rate) ÷ portions. Ingredient cost only — water, cooking fuel, transport, labour, and commercial overheads are not included. All rates are illustrative book planning benchmarks; replace with your live mandi rates.

Cost Driver Composition

10-Portion Base
₹46.95Per Portion
Rohu
₹420.0089%
Mustard oil
₹17.504%
Potatoes
₹12.003%
Onions, ginger, spices, chillies, salt
₹12.003%
Tomatoes
₹8.002%
Sum of Batch Ingredients:₹469.50 / 10 Pax

Interactive Margin & Profit Simulator

Calibrate your catering client quote to verify commercial profit margins.

Optimal Margin (67%)
₹
Pricing Multipliers:
Simulate Catering Batch (100 Pax):

Quoted Revenue

₹14,100

Food Cost

₹4,695

Gross Profit

₹9,405

IngredientQuantityIllustrative RateCost (₹)
Rohu1.2 kg₹350/kg₹420.00
Potatoes300 g₹40/kg₹12.00
Tomatoes200 g₹40/kg₹8.00
Mustard oil50 ml₹350/L₹17.50
Onions, ginger, spices, chillies, salt—₹12 per 10 portions₹12.00
Position in the book: premium end — costs more than 86% of the 175 dishes.

Kitchen Waste Reduction & Yield Strategy

Fish heads and trimmings go into stock; leftover gravy is served over rice the next day.

* Please test this dish in your own kitchen first — quantities are a starting point, not a tasted guarantee. All rates in §11 are illustrative; replace them with your own live supplier / APMC rates.